You Had Me at Pizza

17 Main Street East, Grimsby

You Had Me At Pizza is a sit-down pizzeria just outside downtown Grimsby specializing in sourdough-style pizzas. The menu centres on thoughtfully prepared pies served in a relaxed, dine-in setting.

Seating is designed for longer meals, making it a good choice for visitors looking to settle in rather than grab food on the go. Reviews often reference the comfortable atmosphere and consistent approach. Try the Cinnamon Doughboys for dessert.

Its location within the downtown core makes it a natural dinner stop after shopping or before an evening out nearby.